The Art & Science of Standardization

Worker operating a bottling machine among brewery tanks and wooden barrels

Some of the most important work we do in winemaking is also the least glamorous.

Before the wine, or the blending decisions, or the tastings, and before anyone gets to exercise the creativity we tend to associate with the craft, there is cleaning.

Lots of cleaning!

Tanks. Hoses. Pumps. Barrels. Bottling equipment. There is a process for it. And for good reason.

No winemaker walks into the cellar and says, “I have an innovative idea. Let’s improvise the sanitation protocol today.”

That isn’t where we want creativity. We want consistency because if we cannot trust the fundamentals of the production system, every decision that follows becomes harder to interpret.

That is something I wish more organizations understood.

Standard work doesn’t kill creativity. Poorly designed standard work might. But disciplined standardization creates the conditions for creativity to thrive.

The Vintage can Vary because the Process is Disciplined

Every vintage is different.

Weather changes. Growing conditions change. Fruit chemistry changes. Fermentation behaves differently.

That variability is inherent to winemaking yet our job isn’t to eliminate it. but to understand which variation matters and control the variation that doesn’t.

So we sanitize, test, sample, monitor, and document.

These processes aren’t designed to make every wine identical. They create enough stability around the process that we can focus our judgment on what makes this particular wine different.

That distinction extends far beyond the winery.

Standardize the Routine. Preserve Judgment for the Critical.

Executives sometimes resist standardization because they associate it with bureaucracy.

More procedures. More approvals. Less autonomy. But that confuses standard work with rigid work.

Improvement science approaches standardization differently: Standard work isn’t about eliminating judgment. It’s about deciding where judgment creates value.

I saw this repeatedly during my years working in healthcare! We standardize medication checks, surgical safety practices, infection-prevention protocols, and critical documentation precisely because we don’t want clinicians to reinvent basic safety processes every time they encounter a patient.

That type of standardization doesn’t replace clinical expertise. It protects the cognitive capacity required to use that expertise when something falls outside the expected pathway.

A pilot doesn’t demonstrate creativity by improvising the preflight safety check.

A restaurant doesn’t innovate by allowing every employee to develop their own food-safety practices.

And a winery doesn’t produce a more interesting Cabernet because someone decided sanitation was optional that morning.

Some things should be predictable because other things cannot be!

Standard Work Creates Something Else: A Baseline

There is another reason standardization matters: You cannot reliably improve a process you cannot reliably observe.

Imagine five teams performing the same process five different ways. Performance may appear to improve but why?

Was there a better process? A particularly experienced employee? A temporary workaround? Different operating conditions? Or simply random variation?

Without a reasonably stable process, it becomes difficult to distinguish signal from noise.

Improvement science depends on that distinction: Establish a baseline. Introduce a change. Observe what happens. Learn.

Then determine whether the better method should become the new standard.

This is why I don’t view standard work as the opposite of innovation. Today’s improvement can become tomorrow’s standard work and tomorrow’s standard becomes the baseline from which we improve again.

That is continuous improvement.

Creativity Needs the Right Boundaries

In the winery, I don’t want our creativity invested in whether the equipment was cleaned correctly but in the decisions that shape the wine.

What is the fruit telling us? How is the wine developing? What characteristics should we preserve? Where should we intervene? Where should we leave it alone?

That is where science, experience, judgment, and creativity belong.

The same question should be asked inside organizations: Where are your most capable people spending their judgment?

If highly skilled employees are constantly solving routine problems, recreating basic processes, chasing missing information, or developing workarounds just to get ordinary work done, that isn’t empowerment.

It’s system failure masquerading as flexibility.

For leaders, I reduce the principle to three things:

*Standardize what must be reliable.

*Measure what you want to improve.

*Protect human judgment for the places where it creates disproportionate value.

Because when everything requires improvisation, creativity becomes expensive.

But when the fundamentals are reliable, people have the capacity to experiment, adapt, and solve the problems that actually require them.

So perhaps the leadership question isn’t: Will standardization limit our creativity?

It’s: What could our people create if they didn’t have to keep reinventing what the organization should already know how to do?

Leave a Reply